Meat and markets: Can a global trade in livestock deliver southern Africa out of poverty?
12 August 2010
Trading livestock domestically and regionally, rather than globally, offers the best route out of poverty for southern Africa, according to recent research from the STEPS Centre based at IDS.
The work, funded by the Wellcome Trust's Livestock for Life programme, looked at the beef industry in Botswana, Namibia, South Africa and Zimbabwe, and questioned whether Africa can trade its way out of poverty - a question being posed by many in top policy circles.
Economic growth and employment
Ian Scoones, Professorial Fellow at IDS and Co-Director of the STEPS Centre, explained: 'The idea seems simple. Africa has significant comparative advantage in a range of important commodities with global demand. The growth of such industries can in turn generate economic growth and employment, and this will in turn reduce poverty.
'With extensive grazing, numerous animals and a long tradition of trade in meat to Europe supported by various agreements, surely southern Africa should focus on the global beef trade to generate growth and reduce poverty?'
The STEPS Centre research explored the economic, social and political trade-offs arising from different scenarios for gaining market access and managing and controlling foot-and-mouth disease (FMD) in support of beef production in southern Africa. It showed that there are numerous obstacles to global livestock trade as a route out of poverty.
Barriers to market entry
Professor Scoones said: 'Growing competition from other parts of the world combine with ever-increasing standards which act as barriers to entry to markets. Requirements for "disease freedom" in particular constrain options dramatically when diseases such as FMD are endemic. Subsidies which once kept the industry going and facilitated trade flow have declined and the economics of ranch-based beef production looks shaky compared to other options such as wildlife utilisation.'
These findings are summarised in a recent paper, with the results commented on by an expert panel of researchers, policymakers and industry players.
Following an examination of the new contexts of livestock disease dynamics and trade in southern Africa, the paper explores a series of scenarios for market access, including trade with the European Union, direct exports to large retailers, export to emerging markets (particularly Asia), regional trade in southern Africa, and domestic urban and rural markets.
The paper concludes that:
- A commodity-based trade approach makes sense as a route to safe trade.
- Concentrating on growing domestic and regional markets offers the greatest opportunities.
Such options, it is concluded, offer the most likely route to poverty-reducing trade in southern Africa and beyond.
The STEPS Centre is an interdisciplinary global research and policy engagement hub that unites development studies with science and technology studies. It is funded by the Economic and Social Research Council.
Related Content - News & Blogs
Related Content - Events
CDI Seminar - New evidence on Farmer-centred participatory approaches
6 June 2013 13:00 to 14:30
IDS Convening Space
The Search for Stability through Stabilisation: Case Studies from Afghanistan and Nepal
28 May 2013 13:00 to 14:30
Room 221, Institute of Development Studies
The Damage Done: Inequality, Poverty and Vulnerability
6 May 2014 - 8 May 2014
Institute of Development Studies