Working Paper

MMR Mobilisation: Citizens and Science in a British Vaccine Controversy

Published on 1 January 2005

This paper examines the controversy over measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine in Britain through the lenses of social movement theory and social studies of science.

Since the early 1990s, networks of parents have raised, and mobilised around, concerns that MMR has triggered a particular disease in their children linked to autism and bowel problems, and have been supported in this by certain scientists. In the high-profile and highly-public debate which has ensued, they have challenged established perspectives and institutions in both biomedical science, and public health policy.

While much policy and public debate has dismissed their concerns as based on emotion, misinformation or ‘junk science’, this paper locates them as part of a citizen science grounded in parental experience. It tracks how the framing and strategies of parental mobilisation around MMR have developed, in relation to a growing counter-mobilisation from scientists, policy-makers, health professionals and journalists questioning their claims.

It argues that the controversy involves differently-framed sciences (clinical vs epidemiological) linked to different political commitments (parents’ personal concerns and rights as citizen-consumers vs notions of public health). Each side has nevertheless used similar strategies in deploying science, in exposing the political economy of the other’s science, and in working through the media. Both these differences of framing, and similarities of strategy, are important to comprehending why the debate has become so heated and polarised, and why it has failed to reach closure.

Authors

Melissa Leach

Emeritus Fellow

Publication details

published by
IDS
authors
Leach, M.
journal
IDS Working Paper, issue 247
isbn
978 1 85864 878 5

Share

About this publication

Related content

Brief

Fellows Brief: Epidemic/Pandemic Preparedness in Brazil Amongst Transnational Migrants

SSHAP Briefing

4 October 2024

Brief

From Data to Action: How Findings From an Interagency Rapid Qualitative Assessment are Stimulating Action to Support Drought-Affected Communities in Zambia

SSHAP Briefing

27 September 2024