Graduating from Social Protection?
IDS Bulletin 46.2
Editor Devereux, S. and Sabates-Wheeler, R.
View this publication
To most people, graduation means leaving a school or university after completing a programme of study, once the learner has acquired a set of skills that is expected to equip them for a higher-income future livelihood.
In the development discourse, graduation means leaving a social protection programme after reaching a wellbeing threshold, once the participant has acquired a set of resources that is expected to equip them for a higher-income future livelihood. While poverty reduction is not a new idea, programming for graduation is a relatively new concept.
This IDS Bulletin reviews the conceptualisation and practice of graduation programmes across several countries and diverse contexts, describing what graduation is, how it works, and how to do it. The issue argues that as poverty reduction policies and ambitions for holistic social protection systems evolve, so should aspirations for graduation. Poverty is too complex to be solved with a single instrument such as cash transfers; graduation programmes strive to enhance livelihoods and strengthen resilience by providing integrated packages of support in a holistic effort to address the wide spectrum of resource deficits that keep people trapped in poverty and vulnerability. But the perfect package has not yet been designed. We need to understand the optimal combinations of support for people in different contexts, and the best ways to build linkages and maximise synergies across complementary sectoral interventions.
The achievements of graduation programmes are impressive, offering a fresh approach to tackling poverty and vulnerability. At a time when social protection is moving towards integrated systems and strengthening cross-sectoral linkages with complementary social and economic policies, graduation programmes add real value to efforts to build more secure, sustainable and resilient livelihoods.
Purchase a copy of this IDS Bulletin from the IDS Bookshop.
View abstracts and subscribe to the IDS Bulletin.
Table of contents
Graduating from Social Protection? Editorial Introduction
Stephen Devereux and Rachel Sabates-Wheeler
Exit or Developmental Impact? The Role of 'Graduation' in Social Protection Programmes
The 'Two-fold Investment Trap': Children and their Role in Sustainable Graduation
The Chars Livelihoods Programme in Bangladesh: Factors that Enable, Constrain and Sustain Graduation
Matthew Pritchard, Stuart Kenward and Maksud Hannan
Evaluating Graduation: Insights from the Vision 2020 Umurenge Programme in Rwanda
Vincent Gahamanyi and Andrew Kettlewell
Evidence on Graduation in Practice: Concern Worldwide's Graduation Programme in Rwanda
Ricardo Sabates and Stephen Devereux
Sustaining Graduation: A Review of the CLM Programme in Haiti
Chris Pain, Emilie Vautravers and Alain Descieux
Confidence, Capacity Building and Cash: Achieving Sustained Impact for Ultra-poor Women
Kassie McIlvaine, Corey Oser, Julianna Lindsey and Maia Blume
Is Graduation from Social Safety Nets Possible? Evidence from Sub-Saharan Africa
Silvio Daidone, Luca Pellerano, Sudhanshu Handa and Benjamin Davis
Challenges of Measuring Graduation in Rwanda
Rachel Sabates-Wheeler, Samantha Yates, Emily Wylde and Justine Gatsinzi
Using Real-time Monitoring to Enhance Graduation from Extreme Poverty in Bangladesh
Colin Risner and Vishal Gadhavi
Assets, Asset-ness and Graduation
Sung Kyu Kim and Jim Sumberg
Social Protection and Graduation through Sustainable Employment
Anna McCord and Rachel Slater
Stakeholder Perceptions on Graduation in Ethiopia and Rwanda
Stephen Devereux and Martina Ulrichs