Vocational and technical education is often praised because of its promotion of youth employment, its integration with local labour markets, and its contribution to national development. In West Africa, however, formal technical schooling is often not well integrated with employment markets, leading to underutilised cultural capital and underemployment.
This policy brief explores the reasons for such gaps based on a study of the Healthcare Assistant Certificate offered in Ghana. It lays out how policymakers, the labour market, technical and vocational education services, and educational institutions in Ghana can bridge the gaps between training and employment.
Key messages
- Gaps between vocational training and labour markets are socially produced by interactions and tensions between different social actors, including students, and thus have the potential to be narrowed through political will and social organisation.
- The gap between vocational training and local employment strengthens students’ desire to migrate abroad in the hope of better employment. If gaps are not closed, technical training may primarily benefit other countries, rather than the country which invested in the training.
- Better coordination between different government agencies and the private sector, as well as better regulation of schools and the local labour market which employs certificate holders, could help close the gap.
The Healthcare Assistant Certificate in Ghana
Why do gaps emerge between vocational training and employment? This policy brief examines the case of the Healthcare Assistant Certificate offered by the Ghana Technical and Vocational Education and Training Service (Ghana TVETS) where gaps are leading to the devaluing and possible demise of the qualification, representing the loss of cultural capital and investments by many students and their families.
Background
Ghana TVETS established the Healthcare Assistant Certificate in 2010 at the behest of a nursing agency which was offering homecare services to older adults. Care services were becoming increasingly popular in the capital, Accra, due to an aging population and women’s difficulties balancing care and work responsibilities. The nursing agency wanted a qualification for its workers that could be used as an indicator of quality and to enable them to charge clients more for their services than an untrained domestic servant.
The agency had initially approached the Nursing and Midwifery Council (N&MC), the regulatory body for nurses in Ghana, to develop the course, but N&MC had refused on the grounds of the potential to undermine the role of its nurses. Ghana TVETS’ decision to develop the course is the origin of its tensions with N&MC.
Adapting the curriculum
The Healthcare Assistant course is between six months to a year long, depending on whether it is run as a full-time or three-day-a-week programme. Tuition charges range widely between schools, from 3500 to 6000 cedis (about £225–£400). The only schools offering the Healthcare Assistant programme are private and profit oriented. To boost enrollment, these schools sometimes misrepresent the employment opportunities available following the course.
Enrolled students often hope to work in hospitals rather than domestic elderly care which is seen as degrading. As a result, the certificate has adapted quickly, such that by 2014 its name changed from Carer to Healthcare Assistant. The length of the course has also increased and the curriculum has become a watered-down version of the nursing curriculum. Rather than focusing on important caregiving skills such as safe lifting techniques, exam questions focus on the skills more needed in hospitals than in domestic settings. Clinical attachments for the course usually take place in hospitals, rather than in individual homes or with nursing agencies. Lecturers and assessors are often nurses, sometimes without experience of elderly care.
Competing with nurses for jobs
N&MC has blocked healthcare assistants from getting employment in hospitals due to concerns nurses would be replaced by lower qualified and lower paid staff. It has created its own competing certificate, the Healthcare Assistant Clinical, but this is neither oriented to the home care sector nor to elderly care. Healthcare Assistants face further employment challenges as nursing agencies no longer value their certificate, partly as the curriculum is no longer oriented to domestic elderly care.
A further challenge came in 2020 when, under pressure from the World Bank to curb expenditure, the Ghanaian government halted new postings of nursing graduates to government hospitals. Postings for 2020 graduates were only announced in January 2026. As a result, healthcare assistants have had to compete with nursing school graduates for nursing agency work. The nursing agencies favour employing nurses for the cachet it brings. However, the agencies rarely offer new employees relevant training because it slows their capacity to respond quickly to new patients. Thus, home care agency patients continue to endure relatively untrained care at high cost.
Combined efforts from government bodies would create a more stable employment market for Healthcare Assistant Certificate holders.
Healthcare assistant course applications have dropped dramatically due to limited employment opportunities. There are concerns whether the course remains viable. Ghana TVETS’ figures show a decline in numbers sitting the exam from 5000 in 2015 to only 173 in 2025. However, our research shows these figures are undercounts as the schools studied in our project were missing from these statistics. Two of the five schools we studied offer shorter, cheaper, practical caregiving proficiency courses, developed by the industry and certified by Ghana TVETS, to accommodate working adults. These short courses, however, are also under-subscribed, suggesting a collapse in the value of training workers in elderly care.
Impossible dreams
For the most part, Healthcare Assistant students are not enrolling in the course to work in caregiving in Ghana. Among the 52 students at the five schools we studied, there were three main reasons to enrol:
- The most common reason cited was to support migration abroad. Relying on the certificate to obtain overseas jobs is very uncertain. Recruitment agencies from abroad do not visit the schools, and generally countries like Australia, Canada, the United Kingdom (UK), and the Gulf States only have recruitment programmes for experienced nurses. One graduate we interviewed who was working in the UK had taken a homecare course online to allow her to migrate through a UK recruitment agency. She felt the Ghanaian training had helped her pass the UK home care course, but the accreditation in itself was not useful. This route, however, was closed in July 2025 by the British government because of concerns about abuse by recruiting agencies such as the one our interviewee had used. The new Ghana Labour Exchange Programme opened in the Special Initiatives Office of the President of Ghana in 2025, promises to offer new migration routes for skilled workers, already placing nurses in employment in the Caribbean. However, the programme relies on other countries’ recruitment needs and so far Healthcare Assistant Certificate holders have not been requested.
- The second reason to enrol in the course is as a move into nursing in hospitals. However, entrance into a nursing programme in Ghana requires excellent results in the West African Secondary School Common Entrance exam (WASSCE), and the Healthcare Assistant course does not help with eligibility. Some school directors felt, however, that there should be educational progression between Healthcare Assistant and Nursing programmes. As for working in a hospital, private and public hospitals are regulated by the Health Regulatory Authority and N&MC, and there is limited capacity to employ healthcare assistants. Private hospitals could employ them as ‘support workers’, but not as nurses and, given they try to keep costs down, they do not employ additional staff beyond the requirements determined by the N&MC.
- The third reason students gave was to ‘help people’. Some were already providing care to their households and communities, usually without remuneration. For example, one was teaching Sunday School and another was helping a grandmother. One joined the course because she thought it would be helpful in everyday life because ‘I am a mother’. The students were recognised by others as being good at caring, which was named as ‘nursing’ in popular discourse, and which prompted them to pursue the course.
Student motivations to pursue the Healthcare Assistant Certificate are disconnected from the labour market realities where they must compete with those with nursing degrees and diplomas. Whilst care work is appreciated within their communities, it is not valued as a form of paid work. Students’ desire to migrate means that their families pour resources into their training, but this does not support local staffing, despite the need for more healthcare workers and nurses in Ghana.
Policy recommendations
The Healthcare Assistant Certificate began through coordination between a new employment sector and Ghana TVETS, in which Ghana TVETS supported local industry in designing the course and exam. Despite this auspicious beginning, the certificate has become characterised by multiple disjunctures between the training and the local employment market which has affected student motivation for pursuing the course and has resulted in their underemployment.
This briefing offers four recommendations for policymakers in Ghana, specifically in the Ministry of Health, Ghana TVETS, and N&MC, to close the gaps between training and employment in the healthcare sector:
- The home care sector should be regulated by the state, with standards enshrined to protect patients and workers. Nursing agencies offering homecare services should be registered, and the appropriate certificate(s) for working in the sector outlined. The Ministry of Health should consider using homecare workers to provide post-hospitalisation care to support reduced hospital re-admission and lower healthcare costs. These combined efforts would create a more stable employment market for Healthcare Assistant Certificate holders.
- N&MC and Ghana TVETS should reach an agreement about the future of the Healthcare Assistant course. All health sector training should be offered under the auspices of the appropriate professional body.
- As part of any re-organisation, N&MC should consider allowing bridge programmes into nursing schools, so taking a course like the Healthcare Assistant or working as an elder caregiver could enable an alternative trajectory for entry.
- As the Government of Ghana is dependent on private institutions to
provide training which supports local industries, Ghana TVETS should have greater oversight of these schools to prevent misinformation being given to students.
Further reading
ACET (2022) Strengthening Education and Learning Systems to Deliver a 41R-Reading Workforce, Synthesis report, Accra: African Center for Economic Transformation
Coe, C. (2020) ‘The Enchantment of Neoliberal Education: A Healthcare Certificate, Elusive Adulthoods, and a New Middle Class in Ghana’, Children’s Geographies 18.6: 601–13, DOI: 10.1080/14733285.2020.1740649
Palmer, R. (2020) Lifelong Learning in the Informal Economy: A Literature Review, Geneva: International Labour Organisation
Credits
This IDS Policy Briefing was written by Cati Coe (Carleton University), and is based on research conducted through the ‘Pathways for Vocational Training and Informal Learning in West Africa’ (PAVTIL) project, led by Dorte Thorsen (IDS).
PAVTIL is conducted in three West African countries: Ghana, funded by the Social Science and Humanities Research Council (Canada) (SSHRC) (2004-2024-00214, PI: Cati Coe, co-PI: Akosua Keseboa Darkwah); Benin, funded by Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (AL 515/22-1, PI: Erdmute Alber, co-PI: Clarisse Tama-Imorou); and Côte d´Ivoire, funded by UKRI (363, PI: Dorte Thorsen, co-PI: Affoué Philomène Koffi).
Other members of the research team who contributed to deepening the insights presented here are: Akosua Adu-Poku, Jacob Ahouyao, Samoussiratou Bani, Erik Fanin, and Thanmou Daouda Sero. The author is very grateful to everyone who participated in this research and contributed to these conclusions.
© Institute of Development Studies 2026. This is an Open Access briefing distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International licence (CC BY), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original authors and source are credited and any modifications or adaptations are indicated.