Can you help shape our future priorities? Take a five minute survey now. Survey closes on 8 July.

Journal Article

IDS Bulletin 38.5

Evaluating Science and Risk: Living With and Dying From Asbestos

Published on 1 November 2007

Recent Science and Technology Research has examined how concepts of risk and public understandings of science might be useful in nonWestern contexts (Fairhead and Leach 2003). Pioneering work on how scientific knowledge is embedded in – and interacts with – a cultural context was done by Douglas and Wildavsky (1983) who argued that understanding risk requires an awareness of the sociocultural context alongside knowledge of subjective and personal factors.

Wynne’s interpretationist approach also focuses on context and provides a means to re-examine the more traditionalist, positivist survey approach to public understandings of science (Wynne 1995). His work draws attention to the interaction between ‘formal’ and ‘informal’ forms of expertise, showing how on the Cumbrian fells, sheep farmers interact with physicists.

He also draws attention to the relational dimension of risks, asking ‘how far might lay people be involved in shaping scientific knowledge, and thus in providing the basis for alternative forms of public knowledge that reflect and sustain different dominant conceptions of the human, and of the social purposes of public knowledge?’ (Wynne 1996: 61)

More recently, Furedi has reinforced the centrality of context in his argument that ‘fears about the future are linked to anxieties about problems today. And if the future is feared, then reaction to risk is more likely to emphasize the probability of adverse outcomes’ (Furedi 2002: 18)

Related Content

IDS Bulletin 38.5

Cite this publication

Waldman, L. (2007) Evaluating Science and Risk: Living With and Dying From Asbestos. IDS Bulletin 38(5): 36-49

Authors

Linda Waldman

Director of Teaching and Learning

Publication details

authors
Waldman, Linda
journal
IDS Bulletin, volume 38, issue 5
doi
10.1111/j.1759-5436.2005.tb00407.x
language
English

Share

Related content

Working Paper

Mining Legitimacy: Governing the Politics of Resource-Based Green Industrial Policy

IDS Working Paper 623

3 July 2025

Opinion

The power of communities during civic space closure in Central America

Rocío Elizabeth Ramírez Argueta, Oficial de programas y proyectos, COMCAVIS TRANS

& 3 others

24 June 2025

Opinion

El poder de las comunidades frente al cierre del espacio cívico en Centroamérica

Rocío Elizabeth Ramírez Argueta, Oficial de programas y proyectos, COMCAVIS TRANS

& 3 others

24 June 2025

Opinion

Shaping the future of AI: The role of non-binding agreements

23 June 2025

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.